Yours truly wanted to do a roto basketball league. So what better way to do it than to assemble an army of analysts to play against? Surely my savant-level intuition would suffice, and I would move to fantasy glory, right?
To quote the inimitable Homer Simpson: Doh.
Currently, I have 24 fantasy points, 49 behind leader NBA Fantasy Bible. 14 points behind 9th place Andy Behrens. Dead last in PTS, RB, AST, ST, Fg%, but at least I am first with ten points in the TO category!
So what went wrong? How did such an esteemed writer as yours truly get such a disastrous result? A few lessons.
- Ignoring the Warning Signs: My 3-4 picks were Jalen Duren and Chet Holmgren, neither of whom have done anything. Duren, if you recall, sat out during a contract dispute and clearly wasn’t ramped up enough to avoid injury. Chet also sat most of the preseason, and of course is now out. Losing these top two guys was not just bad luck. It was an unforced error, one that has completely compromised my team build.
What I should have done: Devin Booker, Jaylen Brown, Bam Adebayo were all guys I should have taken instead. Bam really hurts; he’s my favorite player and I only didn’t draft him because I had him in multiple other places. Booker and Brown are scorers and I undervalued that type of player. Taking Booker and Bam was the play, and I whiffed. If I’d done that, I’d have two extra roto PTS category points, six more in RB, three more for AST, and four more in STL. Taking less risky guys would have gotten me 13 extra points in counting stats alone, not to mention Booker’s FT% help and the +4 I’d have had in the BLK category. Just these two moves moved me from 6th place down to the abyss that I’m currently in.
2. Upside Hunting while Forgetting Downside:
Stephon Castle, Naz Reid, and Collin Murray-Boyles were all picked in my top nine players. Breakouts are always fun; drafting too many breakout candidates leads to busts. Castle and CMB were bets on breakouts, and Reid was a bet on increased role. So basically three of my starters had to level up, and the odds were never in favor of that.
What I should have done: Castle was the big whiff with established scorers like Deni Avdija and Pascal Siakam around. Reid also was a reach; Ivica Zubac or Julius Randle would have been more of a boon. If I’d passed on Castle OR Reid even, after crunching the numbers, I’d have an extra 3-4 points in my roto wallet. My gosh, I killed my team! This would at least be a middle-of-the-pack squad.
Bonus Nugget of Info: The main issue I have is that the type of player I like to watch doesn’t always have commensurate fantasy value. For example, my favorite player besides Bam is Aaron Gordon. No, he’s not a fantasy asset. Castle is in the same boat. Fun player. Exciting player. Great watch. Flawed fantasy asset. CMB probably falls into the same bucket. I also HATE one-dimensional scoring players and need to learn how and when to draft them.
3. Balance vs. Category Dominance:
Man, leave me alone I HAD anchors, they just got hurt! No, I did NOT read point one about ignoring warning signs! The problem is that I stopped building around my anchors and my strength and kept drafting players I liked. My team is fun to root for at least.
I did start the draft with Tyrese Maxey and Jalen Johnson, a quite happy and defensible start. Desmond Bane in the fifth wasn’t terrible. Now if I had added Avdija, Zubac, and Zach LaVine to that group? Oh, the humanity! I would feel bad about the beatdown that would commence. Unfortunately, I don’t really enjoy watching any of them play and Bulls fans who know about me will remember that LaVine is my second least favorite Bull of all time. In a tough room, though, these feelings need to be suppressed.
The Final Lesson
I need to learn once again to be a fantasy basketball player, not a fan collecting players that I like to watch. Fit matters, category dominance is important, and my favorite players aren’t necessarily the ones that are going to help me win.
End note: League includes these awesome follows: